Get a Free Quote

St. Louis the Best Option Metal Shingles vs. Standing Seam Metal Roofs

Mar 23, 2021

Investing in a new metal roof for your St. Louis home is one of the best decisions you can make, but it is vital to have all the information available about the roofing materials to choose the metal roof that is best for you. When you have the information at your fingertips that allows you to evaluate all of the pros and cons, it is easier to make a choice that you will be happy with for many years. One of the top questions that homeowners have when they start looking at metal roofs is whether standing seam metal roofs or stamped metal shingle roofs are better. The best way to decide which is best for you is to be educated about each detail before making a decision.

The Advantages of Stamped Metal Shingle Roofing

These small, modular panels are popular because they are pressed to create a look that simulates slate, tile, shake, and other shingle styles. Consider the benefits these shingles offer.

  • Energy efficiency. These metal shingles are typically coated with a highly reflective paint reflecting the sun’s rays and dispels radiant heat. This helps your home stay cool without putting too much pressure on your cooling system and lower your utility costs.
  • By their very nature, metal roofs have a longer lifespan than asphalt shingles and many other roofing materials. A benefit of most stamped metal shingle roofs is that they feature concealed fasteners protected from exposure to the damaging effects of the elements.
  • One of the benefits of metal shingle installation is that its low-profile design allows for easy handling, making clean flashing details easy for contractors to achieve.
  • Re-roofing. Many homeowners choose to install their new metal roof over an old asphalt roof to save on construction costs and prevent the old shingles from going to the landfill. Stamped metal shingle design is perfect for re-roofing because their deep grooves keep the shingles raised above the old roof, creating an airspace that gives the new roof a more even appearance.
  • The vast array of colors, styles, and designs that stamped metal shingles offer give homeowners a great deal of flexibility in choosing a style that matches their home’s architectural design. This also offers homeowners who must adhere to HOA restrictions metal roofing options that fit their requirements. For others who don’t like to deviate from tradition, this makes the decision to install a metal roof easier because metal shingles are available in a look that resembles the asphalt shingles on most homes in the U.S.

Benefits of Standing Seam Metal Roofs

Many homeowners in Missouri prefer the look and features of standing seam metal roofs, which have raised vertical seams, or legs and a flat area in between. This metal roof style is popular on commercial and industrial buildings, but many homeowners find that it works perfectly in residential applications as well.

  • Energy savings. Just like stamped shingle metal roofs, standing seam options are also energy efficient and lower cooling costs.
  • Architectural versatility. Standing seam metal roofs are ideal for homes with complex, sophisticated designs. The sleek, straight lines offer a clean, modern look that complements many different architectural designs. They are also available in various colors, allowing homeowners to select the perfect look for their house.
  • There are two types of standing seam metal roofs, which allow for versatility when it comes to the pitch of your home’s roof. Mechanically seamed double lock systems are great for low-slope roofs, while snap-lock systems are better suited to pitches of 3/12 and above.
  • One advantage of note that standing seam metal roofs offer over stamped shingle varieties is the metal thickness. Stamped shingles are more vulnerable to damage from branches and other objects hitting the roof, and standing seam metal roofs are available in thicknesses between 22 and 26 gauge, making them a sturdier choice.
  • Industry-standard testing. For homes in high wind and hurricane-prone environments, standing seam metal roofs are a great choice because they are tested to meet industry standards for wind uplift. Other testing measures are also taken for impact and fire resistance, water submersion, water penetration, and air leakage.
  • Standing seam metal roofs offer a 50+ year lifespan, compared to the 40+ years of stamped metal shingles. Although both styles are low maintenance and offer great durability, many homeowners prefer the option that will last the longest.

Disadvantages of Stamped Metal Shingles

  • Industry standards. Stamped metal shingle roofs are not held to the same testing standards as standing seam metal roofs and rarely offer the same warranty coverage. If you are looking for a weathertight warranty, you are not likely to find it with stamped metal shingle roofs.
  • If your roof’s pitch is lower than 3/12, stamped metal shingles are not an optimal choice, as they may allow rainwater to pool and damage your home. This is especially true in areas with high rainfall and those that are prone to a lot of snow and ice.
  • If you are looking for the most bang for your buck, you will typically find that standing seam metal roofs are less expensive than stamped metal shingles. When you combine that with the fact that stamped metal has a shorter lifespan, the standing seam option is the more economical choice.

Cons of Standing Seam Metal Roofing

  • Oil canning. This characteristic of some standing seam metal roofs creates a wavy appearance that some find unappealing. Although it is only aesthetic and doesn’t affect the roof’s performance or longevity, it is a factor to consider.
  • Homeowner association restrictions. Many HOAs do not allow standing seam metal roofs because they feel that they are inconsistent with the “style” of the neighborhood or look too industrial. Some also cite high glare as a reason for not allowing these roofs.
  • Complex installation. It is sometimes difficult to find a qualified contractor to install a standing seam metal roof because it is a labor-intensive process that requires experience and skill to ensure proper installation.
  • Although standing seam metal roofs are typically less expensive than stamped metal shingles, they are still more expensive than many other roofing materials. Many homeowners, however, find that the longevity of the product makes the expense worthwhile.

When you begin choosing your metal roofing products with a basic understanding of the materials available, it is easier to choose the best product for your St. Louis home. A trustworthy metal roofing contractor will discuss your options with you and help you make the wisest decision.

4.6 Rating
Based on over 16,558+ Reviews on bbb.org and guildquality.com
The installation team was a real pleasure dealing with. They were very polite, friendly and knowledgeable. They even took the time to make a cozy hang out in our yard with the fire ring and...
Dianne M.
Product: general
Great company. Good product and reasonable prices. Very professional. As a construction worker myself it's nice to see a contractor that is on the ball. I would definitely hire them again!
David B.
Product: general
The Sales reps were very informative and respected the fact that I had done significant research in advance. As such, I had to keep prompting them to skip the sales pitch and get to the...
Gary S.
Product: general
I'm most satisfied with the aesthetics of the overall job. The roof seems to be doing a great job, and I don't have any problems with my roof anymore.
Samantha P.
Product: general
Great company great experience. We love our roof and appreciate the salesman and install crews. We would defiantly recommend Erie to anyone.
Bob P.
Product: general
The Nation’s Leading Provider of Ultra-Durable, Attractive Metal Roofing
Decades of Experience
Erie Home has installed thousands of metal roofs on homes throughout the country since our founding in 1976. We’re proud to have maintained a sterling reputation for both the quality of our products and our installations.
Learn About Us
Limited Lifetime Warranty
Erie metal roofs are designed to last. Through decades of exposure to intense sun, hail, and strong winds, your new roof will continue to protect your home without needing frequent upkeep.
Register Your Warranty
Factory-Trained Installers
Every metal roofing project is completed by extensively experienced, factory-trained and -certified technicians. You can have peace of mind knowing that your project is in the most capable of hands.
Learn About Our Team
Our Locations
11900 Baltimore Ave Suite F, Beltsville, Maryland 20705
See All Locations
4.6 out of 16,558 Reviews
Call Now 1-800-612-6000 FREE Quote Chat Now Menu